hagbard_celine
06-02-2007, 07:33 PM
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6334769.stm
This news story is very revealing when it comes to the tragedy of war, but it’s actually far more tragic than it appears at first glance. Tragic in that this world is so insanely two-faced!
An inquest is being held today into the killing of a British soldier L/Co Matty Hull by American pilots in a “blue-on-blue”, an incident where an ally is attacked by mistake. The inquest is receiving a lot of publicity and probably costing a lot of money. The TV showed pictures of Matty Hull’s grieving widow and black-box footage of the American pilots involved. The American pilots engage a tank which they think is Iraqi, then the command centre informs them that the tank is actually British. The pilots are devastated at the news; one of them even says “I’m going to be sick!”
The thing which bothers me is that this whole affair, with all its costs and publicity, is only taking place because the attacker and victim were “on the same side”. If the tank had been Iraqi then there would have been no inquest, no compensation for the victim’s family, little or no publicity; and would the pilots have been as deeply hurt and sickened as they were? Probably not. I’ve seen similar black-box footage of American pilots screaming with elation and excitement as they blow up Iraqi targets. Why? The “enemy” targets are people too, with parents, widows and partners (They’re probably more likely to have partners than any other men because of the status and prestige the Conformist Regime pours upon the military). They’re every bit as much human beings as Matty Hull.
Many people will say that the answer is obvious: This was war and the two “sides” are “enemies”. Well, this is even worse! The one and only thing which makes the difference in attitude towards the killing of Matty Hull and identical Iraqi targets is political bureaucratic orders! If the orders were different then the “enemy forces” could well be allies; then they’d probably be having a drink together in the NAAFI and getting along fine!
It’s often the most obvious questions that never get asked!
If this is sanity then thank God I’m crazy!
This news story is very revealing when it comes to the tragedy of war, but it’s actually far more tragic than it appears at first glance. Tragic in that this world is so insanely two-faced!
An inquest is being held today into the killing of a British soldier L/Co Matty Hull by American pilots in a “blue-on-blue”, an incident where an ally is attacked by mistake. The inquest is receiving a lot of publicity and probably costing a lot of money. The TV showed pictures of Matty Hull’s grieving widow and black-box footage of the American pilots involved. The American pilots engage a tank which they think is Iraqi, then the command centre informs them that the tank is actually British. The pilots are devastated at the news; one of them even says “I’m going to be sick!”
The thing which bothers me is that this whole affair, with all its costs and publicity, is only taking place because the attacker and victim were “on the same side”. If the tank had been Iraqi then there would have been no inquest, no compensation for the victim’s family, little or no publicity; and would the pilots have been as deeply hurt and sickened as they were? Probably not. I’ve seen similar black-box footage of American pilots screaming with elation and excitement as they blow up Iraqi targets. Why? The “enemy” targets are people too, with parents, widows and partners (They’re probably more likely to have partners than any other men because of the status and prestige the Conformist Regime pours upon the military). They’re every bit as much human beings as Matty Hull.
Many people will say that the answer is obvious: This was war and the two “sides” are “enemies”. Well, this is even worse! The one and only thing which makes the difference in attitude towards the killing of Matty Hull and identical Iraqi targets is political bureaucratic orders! If the orders were different then the “enemy forces” could well be allies; then they’d probably be having a drink together in the NAAFI and getting along fine!
It’s often the most obvious questions that never get asked!
If this is sanity then thank God I’m crazy!